Sample Cases from our office
These are some sample cases from our files. It is impossible for us to highlight all we have done in the past thirty years of our practice. These are just some of the cases that come to mind.
Type of case: Successful response to an audit of a submitted ETA Form 9089 (PERM)
Category: EB2 Green Card, PERM - Labor Certification, DOL
We assisted a client company in filing an EB-2-based PERM. The submitted ETA Form 9089 was selected for an audit by DOL. They requested evidence/explanation as to why only the specified combination of a higher degree and significant years of experience were required, beyond the normal requirements defined by O*Net, a source of occupational data often cited by the government. Our response included a significant amount of documentation and an extensive and detailed support letter presenting the case and context as to why the specifics of this particular employer’s product and the beneficiary’s role required a relatively high and indispensable level of both education and experience. The ETA 9089 was then certified.
Status: Our response included a significant amount of documentation and an extensive and detailed support letter presenting the case and context as to why the specifics of this particular employer’s product and the beneficiary’s role required a relatively high and indispensable level of both education and experience. The ETA 9089 was then certified.
DISCLAIMER: PAST APPROVAL OF A CASE IS NOT A GUARANTEE OR PREDICTION REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF FUTURE CASES. CASE RESULTS DEPEND UPON A VARIETY OF FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE.
-----------------------
Type of case: MTR approved by DOL on engineering issue
Category: PERM - Labor Certification, DOL, Engineers, Computer and IT Professionals
USDOL had denied a series of cases for many employers represented by various law firms. The ground of denial was that when "engineering" was one of the acceptable majors for an IT job, that created too much ambiguity for a case to be approved. DOL stated that there are fields of engineering, such as Agricultural Engineering, which are clearly inapplicable to IT positions.
This ruling had become a nation wide issue.
We filed an MTR pointing out the defects, legal and factual, in the ruling. We also indicated our willingness to litigate this highly unfair ruling in federal courts. DOL has, most appropriately, reversed their decision.
DISCLAIMER: PAST APPROVAL OF A CASE IS NOT A GUARANTEE OR PREDICTION REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF FUTURE CASES. CASE RESULTS DEPEND UPON A VARIETY OF FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE.
-----------------------
Type of case: PERM Proof of Advertising Materials
Category: EB2 Green Card, PERM - Labor Certification
We represented a consulting company and their employee, a Senior Quality Assurance Analyst. USDOL had denied PERM certification after an audit holding that we had failed to submit tear sheets from our Sunday advertisements. We filed the appropriate motion establishing that it was highly likely, if not certain, that the tear sheets were in fact submitted. We provided evidence from our files, affidavits, and proof of our firm’s normal business practice.The case was approved in less than three weeks.
DISCLAIMER: PAST APPROVAL OF A CASE IS NOT A GUARANTEE OR PREDICTION REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF FUTURE CASES. CASE RESULTS DEPEND UPON A VARIETY OF FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE.
-----------------------
Type of case: EB-2 PERM, Government Error
Category: EB2 Green Card, PERM - Labor Certification
We represented a technology consulting services corporation and a Senior Programmer Analyst employed by the firm. We submitted electronically the applicant’s labor certification (PERM) to the USDOL. They denied certification without a request for explanation or audit. The USDOL denial alleged that the employer was required to show on the ETA 9089 (the PERM form) what methodology was used for the foreign degree evaluation. We responded with appropriatemotion showing that this was clearly government error and a violation of due process. The forms provide no way of stating this information. We further presented several legal arguments and cases in support of our clearly justified position. Unfortunately, there is no way to spare anguish and uncertainty inflicted upon our clients, but USDOL did recognize the error and moved to correct it.
The case was approved within four weeks.
DISCLAIMER: PAST APPROVAL OF A CASE IS NOT A GUARANTEE OR PREDICTION REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF FUTURE CASES. CASE RESULTS DEPEND UPON A VARIETY OF FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE.
-----------------------
Type of case: PERM, Supervise Recruitment, Qualified Job Applicant
Category: PERM - Labor Certification
We represented an IT consulting company and a Technical Project Lead employed by them. The PERM was selected for supervised recruitment. USDOL denied certification, alleging that the employer rejected a potentially qualified U.S. applicant without an interview. This is one of the cases where our firm’s knowledge of various fields, including IT, paid off. The job offered required high-end database experience. The job applicant possessed only MS Access experience. We established on the record that MS Access experience could not possibly translate into working with high-end databases in multi-million dollar projects. We submitted copious amounts of evidence, including data from federal government IT deployments and case law. We argued that the U.S. applicant was not qualified, could not possibly qualify for the position, and that an interview was not required because hiring the U.S. applicant would necessitate an unreasonable amount of on-the-job training.
The case was approved in about two weeks.
DISCLAIMER: PAST APPROVAL OF A CASE IS NOT A GUARANTEE OR PREDICTION REGARDING THE OUTCOME OF FUTURE CASES. CASE RESULTS DEPEND UPON A VARIETY OF FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE.
-----------------------
By Year
By Category
Nonimmigrant Visas
Immigration Law
Immigration.com
Green Card
Profession/Occupation
Citizenship and Naturalization
Law Offices of Rajiv S. Khanna, PC
5225 Wilson Blvd, Arlington, VA 22205
110 W. Johnson St, Suite 213, Staunton, VA 24401
Ph: (202) 909-1110
Copyright ©1993-2026, Law Offices of Rajiv S. Khanna, PC. All rights reserved.
IMMIGRATION.COM is a registered trademark of Law Offices of Rajiv S. Khanna, P.C.